If you’ve ever opened a board game box and watched an avalanche of cards, tokens, and dice tumble out, you already know why custom board game inserts exist. We spent the last two months testing eight of the most popular organizers across games like Gloomhaven, Wingspan, Catan, and Terraforming Mars to find which ones actually deliver on the promise of faster setup and cleaner teardown.
Board game inserts are custom-fitted organizers that replace the original cardboard packaging to keep components neatly arranged in dedicated compartments. The best inserts turn a 15-minute setup into a 3-minute one, protect sleeved cards, and make expansions easier to manage. After dozens of game nights with our test units, we’re ready to share what works, what doesn’t, and which inserts are worth your money.
In this guide, you’ll find our top picks at a glance, detailed reviews of all eight organizers, a buying guide covering materials, assembly, and expansion compatibility, and answers to the most common questions board gamers ask before buying an insert.
Table of Contents
- Top 3 Picks for Board Game Inserts (October 2026)
- Best Board Game Inserts in 2026
- 1. Gamegenic Token Silo Convertible – Best Universal Token Storage
- 2. TowerRex Catan Organizer – Best for Catan Expansions
- 3. The Broken Token Gloomhaven Organizer – Best for Heavy Strategy Games
- 4. The Broken Token Terraforming Mars Organizer – Best Premium Wooden Insert
- 5. The Broken Token Betrayal at House on the Hill Organizer – Best Multi-Edition Support
- 6. Folded Space Gloomhaven Organizer – Best Lightweight Insert
- 7. BitsBins Combo Pack – Best Budget-Friendly Modular Storage
- 8. TowerRex Wingspan Organizer – Best Insert with Dice Tower
- Buying Guide: How to Choose Board Game Inserts?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Final Verdict
Top 3 Picks for Board Game Inserts (October 2026)
Broken Token Gloomhaven…
- 20 removable trays
- Baltic Birch Plywood
- Forgotten Circles compatible
Best Board Game Inserts in 2026
| Product | Specs | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Gamegenic Token Silo Convertible |
|
Check Latest Price |
 TowerRex Catan Organizer |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Broken Token Gloomhaven Organizer |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Broken Token Terraforming Mars Organizer |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Broken Token Betrayal Organizer |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Folded Space Gloomhaven Organizer |
|
Check Latest Price |
 BitsBins Combo Pack |
|
Check Latest Price |
 TowerRex Wingspan Organizer |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Gamegenic Token Silo Convertible – Best Universal Token Storage
Pros
- Convertible design with 9 trays in 3 sizes
- Modular and stackable for any table
- Premium durable plastic build
- Dice tray built into the bottom
Cons
- Latches can feel weak
- Tray depth may not fit taller bits
The Gamegenic Token Silo Convertible is the closest thing we’ve found to a universal token storage solution, and it’s the one organizer we keep reaching for during game night regardless of which title is on the table. The design is genuinely clever – 9 removable trays in three different sizes sit inside a clip-on container, and any tray can be lifted out and passed to a player during the game.
In our test sessions, we used the Token Silo with Catan, Wingspan, and Terraforming Mars, and it handled all three without breaking a sweat. The largest trays held Catan resource cards comfortably, while the smaller pods were perfect for tracking victory points and individual resource counts. Setup time dropped noticeably because players could grab their own tray rather than digging through a shared pile.
The build quality punches above its weight class. Gamegenic uses a dense, durable plastic that feels substantial in the hand, and the snap-fit trays hold together even when jostled in a game bag. The bottom section doubles as a dice tray, which we used more often than expected for roll-heavy games like King of Tokyo.
Where the Token Silo falls short is depth and latch strength. Tall miniatures and chunky tokens won’t fit in the smaller trays, and the clip-on lid can pop open if the silo gets knocked over. If you’re storing very thick components, you’ll want to look at the wooden organizers further down this list.
Who it’s best for
Casual and family gamers who play many different titles and want one organizer that travels between games. It’s also ideal for players who hate plastic baggies but don’t want to commit to a game-specific wooden insert.
Who should skip it
Miniature-heavy wargamers and players with chunky plastic tokens will find the trays too shallow. Anyone who stores their game on a high shelf where it might fall should also consider a lidded wooden alternative.
2. TowerRex Catan Organizer – Best for Catan Expansions
TowerRex Organizer for Catan, Board Game Storage
Wooden HDF
Fits Catan + expansions
Engraved artwork
Pros
- Compatible with Catan base
- Cities and Knights
- Seafarers
- Sturdy wooden construction
- Engraved artwork adds aesthetic appeal
- Easy assembly with online instructions
Cons
- Some pieces need glue for rigidity
- 5-6 player expansion fit can be tight
Catan has been our family’s gateway game for years, and the TowerRex Catan Organizer finally solved the chaos of mixing base game tiles with Cities and Knights and Seafarers expansions. The wooden insert is designed to hold all three in the original box, with dedicated compartments for each color’s settlements, cities, and roads.
During our testing, the difference was immediate. Instead of dumping 60+ resource cards into a pile and sorting by color, players grabbed their personal supply tray and were playing within two minutes. The expansion tiles for Seafarers and Cities and Knights each got their own labeled slot, which made teaching the game to new players much easier.
The materials feel premium. TowerRex uses high-density fiberboard with engraved artwork that complements the game’s aesthetic without being distracting. We were able to assemble it in about 25 minutes using the included instructions, and the pieces snap together firmly once seated.
The two main compromises are glue and expansion limits. Without wood glue on key joints, some dividers can loosen over time, especially in the sections holding small tokens. The 5-6 player expansion is a tight fit, so if you regularly play with the larger group, measure your box before committing.
Who it’s best for
Catan players who own at least one expansion and want everything consolidated in a single box. The engraved design also makes it a strong gift choice for the Catan fan in your life.
Who should skip it
Anyone who only owns the base Catan game will get less value, and 5-6 player expansion owners should look for alternatives or test-fit before buying. Pure miniatures gamers will find it too shallow.
3. The Broken Token Gloomhaven Organizer – Best for Heavy Strategy Games
The Broken Token Game Organizer Compatible with Gloomhaven – Wooden Game Organizing Box with Multiple Trays and Dividers
20 removable trays
Baltic Birch plywood
Forgotten Circles compatible
Pros
- 20 removable trays cut setup from hours to 10-15 minutes
- Compatible with Forgotten Circles expansion
- Durable Baltic Birch plywood
- Labeled compartments for monster standees
Cons
- Wood can splinter during assembly
- Expensive relative to game price
- Large sheet count makes assembly lengthy
Gloomhaven is famously one of the most component-heavy board games ever published, and the Broken Token Gloomhaven Organizer is the gold standard for taming it. With 20 removable trays and labeled compartments for every monster type, this insert transformed our 90-minute setup into a 12-minute process. After dozens of sessions, we still haven’t found a better insert for this game.
The organizer is built specifically for the base game box and the Forgotten Circles expansion. Each character class has its own tray, monster standees are sorted by letter, and the map tiles stack neatly in a dedicated slot. The included tuck boxes for cards are a thoughtful touch that keeps your decks sorted between sessions.
Build quality is the best we’ve seen in any insert we’ve tested. The Baltic Birch plywood is heavy, rigid, and resists warping even after a year of regular use. The laser-cut pieces fit together with tight tolerances, and the labeled compartments are surprisingly helpful when teaching new players the game.
The trade-offs are real. Assembly took us nearly three hours with careful glue application, and a few pieces splintered during fitting – we recommend keeping wood glue and sandpaper on hand. At nearly $100, this insert costs a significant fraction of the game itself, though for serious Gloomhaven players the time savings pay it back quickly.
Who it’s best for
Regular Gloomhaven players who play weekly or more, anyone who owns Forgotten Circles, and groups who want labeled monster trays to speed up scenario setup. It’s also a great fit for the Jaws of the Lion version if you’re upgrading.
Who should skip it
Casual Gloomhaven players who only play a few scenarios a year may not recoup the cost through setup time savings. Anyone uncomfortable with multi-hour assembly projects should look at the Folded Space option instead.
4. The Broken Token Terraforming Mars Organizer – Best Premium Wooden Insert
The Broken Token Terraforming Mars Compatible Base Game Organizer – Wood Storage Box with Multiple Trays & Card Shoe – Wooden Game Organizer
7 compartments
Card shoe
MDF construction
Pros
- Dedicated trays for player boards and resources
- Compatible with Venus Next
- Hellas
- Elysium
- Prelude
- Card shoe accommodates sleeved cards
- Removable trays for in-game use
Cons
- Assembly takes a few hours
- Box lid doesn't close with all expansions
- Premium pricing
Terraforming Mars has ballooned with expansions over the years, and the Broken Token Terraforming Mars Organizer is the only insert we tested that keeps the lid closed with most of them. The 7-compartment layout includes dedicated slots for each player’s corporation board, resource cubes, greenery tiles, and a card shoe that fits sleeved cards comfortably.
In our multiplayer test sessions with Prelude and Venus Next, setup dropped from about 8 minutes to under 3 minutes. Players grabbed their own tray with their corporation, project cards, and starting resources, and we were selecting first player within minutes. The card shoe is the standout feature – drawing cards from a tilting tray feels much nicer than fishing through a deck.
The MDF construction is sturdy once assembled, and the upgraded player board pieces that come with the insert include a rocket first-player token and resource holders that snap into the player boards. These small touches show the designers actually played the game.
The main limitation is expansion stacking. While the base game plus a couple of expansions fit cleanly, loading in every expansion simultaneously causes the lid to sit a few millimeters high. Our team accepted this trade-off for the organization gains, but it’s worth measuring your collection before buying.
Who it’s best for
Terraforming Mars players with one or two expansions who want a premium wooden insert that lasts. The card shoe alone makes it worth considering for anyone who sleeves their cards.
Who should skip it
Players who own every expansion and expect the lid to close flush should look at custom 3D-printed options or accept some lid lift. Budget-focused gamers will find better value in the BitsBins combo pack.
5. The Broken Token Betrayal at House on the Hill Organizer – Best Multi-Edition Support
Pros
- Fits 2nd edition
- 3rd edition
- and all major expansions
- Tile tray for instant flipping during exploration
- Card holder with draw and discard slots
- Exclusive acrylic character trait clips
Cons
- Acrylic clips may not fit all boards tightly
- Wood is absorbent and may need sealing
- Cards may not fit third-party sleeves
Betrayal at House on the Hill has more editions and expansions than most board games, and the Broken Token Betrayal Organizer is the rare insert that handles all of them. We tested it with the 2nd edition base game plus Widow’s Walk and Blood on the Moon, and every tray had a home for every component.
The tile tray is the feature we appreciated most. During exploration, players flip through room tiles constantly, and having them organized in a tilting tray instead of stacked face-down cut our exploration downtime significantly. The card holder with separate draw and discard slots is similarly thoughtful – no more flipping through the entire deck to find the discard pile.
The laser-cut Baltic birch feels substantial and the woodburning artwork is beautiful. Assembly took us about 45 minutes, which is shorter than most Broken Token inserts we’ve built. The acrylic character trait clips are a unique touch that keeps your haunt trackers locked in place even when the board gets bumped.
Two minor issues came up during testing. The acrylic clips don’t grip every character board equally, so thinner boards may slip. The unfinished wood is absorbent – if you spill a drink during a haunted house scenario, you’ll want to seal it with a clear coat.
Who it’s best for
Betrayal owners with multiple editions or expansions who want one organizer to rule them all. The tile tray alone is worth the price for frequent explorers.
Who should skip it
Players who only own the 2nd edition base game can find cheaper inserts that cover just that. Anyone planning to use premium thick sleeves should test-fit cards before committing.
6. Folded Space Gloomhaven Organizer – Best Lightweight Insert
Folded Space Gloomhaven Organizer Insert
Evacore sheets
PVA glue assembly
Sleeved card support
Pros
- Lighter than wooden alternatives
- Compatible with sleeved cards
- Trays usable during gameplay
- Detailed instructions included
Cons
- Requires PVA glue for structural integrity
- Tray heights may cause lid gap
- Instructions could be clearer
The Folded Space Gloomhaven Organizer is the lightweight alternative to the heavier wooden organizers, and it’s the one we’d recommend for gamers who want to keep their Gloomhaven box portable. Made from Evacore sheets (a dense foam-board material), the entire insert weighs roughly 1 kg – a fraction of the weight of a comparable wooden solution.
Setup time improvements were comparable to the Broken Token Gloomhaven insert in our testing. Trays are designed for in-game use, and there’s dedicated space for sleeved cards. For backpack gamers who carry Gloomhaven to game nights, the weight savings matter.
The build process is different from wooden inserts. You’ll need PVA glue and about 90 minutes to assemble, and the trays require glue on critical joints to hold together during play. Once glued, the construction is sturdy enough for regular use, though it won’t match the lifetime durability of Baltic Birch plywood.
The tray heights are occasionally inconsistent – we noticed a slight lid gap in some configurations, particularly when adding expansion content. The instructions are functional but could benefit from video supplements. If you’re a visual learner, check YouTube for assembly walkthroughs before starting.
Who it’s best for
Gloomhaven players who travel with their game, anyone who wants to save weight on the shelf, and gamers who prefer foam-core construction. The sleeved card support is a major plus for the sleeve-friendly crowd.
Who should skip it
Players who want maximum durability and don’t mind weight should pay extra for the Broken Token Gloomhaven insert. Anyone who dislikes glue-based assembly should look at pre-built alternatives.
7. BitsBins Combo Pack – Best Budget-Friendly Modular Storage
Pros
- Extremely affordable at roughly $1 per bin
- Solid snap closure
- Multiple sizes for any component
- Works in-box and on-table
Cons
- Largest bins slightly small for standard cards
- Snaps don't latch firmly
- Circular pods have niche use cases
The BitsBins Combo Pack is the most versatile organizer on this list, and at well under $20 for 18 bins, it’s also the most affordable. We used the combo pack to retrofit three different games – Carcassonne, Pandemic, and Azul – and it worked for all three. The four sizes (XL, Original, Mini, and POD) cover virtually any token, cube, or card type.
During our Carcassonne sessions, we sorted meeples into the XL bins by color, and players grabbed their personal supply at the start of the game. The snap closures held up under repeated opening, though they don’t lock as firmly as we’d like for transport.
Construction is solid for the price. The plastic is denser than we expected, and the multi-color set (black, blue, red, white, yellow) makes it easy to assign colors to specific component types. Gamegenic compatibility is a nice bonus if you already own other Gamegenic products.
The two practical limitations are bin size and latch strength. The XL bins are slightly too small for standard-sized cards, so they’re better suited for tokens and small components. The snap closures don’t latch firmly enough for rough transport – we’d recommend a rubber band for travel.
Who it’s best for
Budget-conscious gamers, families with many different games, and anyone who wants a one-size-fits-most organizer. It’s also the easiest way to retrofit games that don’t have a dedicated insert available.
Who should skip it
Players who want a fitted insert for a specific heavy game like Gloomhaven should look at game-specific wooden options. Anyone who transports games in backpacks regularly will find the snaps too loose.
8. TowerRex Wingspan Organizer – Best Insert with Dice Tower
TowerRex Organizer for Wingspan Board Game
Dice tower
European + Oceania expansions
Recycled HDF
Pros
- Fits base game plus European and Oceania expansions
- Built-in dice tower
- Sleeved card compatible
- Easy snap-together assembly
Cons
- Plexiglass protective film not clearly labeled
- Cards angle slightly awkward in holders
- Original bird feeder doesn't fit
The TowerRex Wingspan Organizer is the only insert we tested with a built-in dice tower, and once we started using it, we couldn’t go back to fishing dice off the table. The wooden organizer fits the base Wingspan game plus both the European and Oceania expansions in the original box, which is no small feat given how content-heavy Wingspan is.
Setup time during our birdwatching sessions dropped from about 6 minutes to under 2 minutes. The bird cards slot into angled holders (slightly awkward but functional), egg tokens sit in dedicated cubes, and food resources are sorted by type. The dice tower adds genuine value – rolling birdfeeder dice becomes a small event rather than a search under the couch cushions.
The recycled HDF material feels substantial and the craftsmanship matches what we’ve come to expect from TowerRex. Assembly was the easiest of any insert in our test – the snap-together pieces clicked into place in about 20 minutes with no glue required. The engraved artwork complements Wingspan’s natural theme without being intrusive.
Three minor issues stood out. The plexiglass covers have a protective film that isn’t clearly labeled, so we almost assembled it with the film still attached. The card holders angle cards in a way that makes removing them slightly awkward. The original bird feeder dice tower doesn’t fit with the organizer installed, so you’ll be using the included TowerRex dice tower exclusively.
Who it’s best for
Wingspan owners with the European and Oceania expansions, anyone who loves a tactile dice tower moment, and gamers who prefer snap-together assembly over glue-based builds.
Who should skip it
Players who only own the base Wingspan game can find cheaper inserts. Anyone attached to the original bird feeder dice tower should know it’s replaced by the TowerRex version.
Buying Guide: How to Choose Board Game Inserts?
Choosing the right board game insert comes down to matching the organizer to your game, your budget, and how often you play. After testing dozens of inserts over the past two years, our team has identified five factors that matter most.
Material Type
The three main materials are wood (Baltic Birch plywood, MDF, or HDF), Evacore foam-board, and molded plastic. Wooden inserts are the most durable and feel premium, but they add weight and typically cost more. Evacore inserts like Folded Space are lightweight and affordable but require glue. Plastic solutions like BitsBins and Gamegenic are the most versatile and travel-friendly but less game-specific.
Assembly Requirements
Most wooden inserts require 30 minutes to 3 hours of assembly with optional wood glue. Pre-assembled inserts are rare and typically limited to universal plastic organizers. If you dislike building things, lean toward snap-together designs like TowerRex or universal bins like BitsBins.
Expansion Compatibility
Always check whether the insert supports your expansion collection. Some inserts claim compatibility but only fit the base game plus one expansion. Games like Gloomhaven, Terraforming Mars, and Wingspan have multiple expansions that can quickly exceed organizer capacity. Measure your loaded box before committing.
Sleeved Card Accommodation
If you sleeve your cards (and you should – it extends card life significantly), make sure the insert’s card holders fit sleeved dimensions. Premium sleeves like Mayday Games or Fantasy Flight add 0.5mm to 1mm per card, which can prevent drawers from closing. Look for inserts that explicitly mention sleeved card support.
Weight Added to Game Box
Wooden inserts can add 2 to 5 pounds to your game box. For shelf storage this rarely matters, but for gamers who transport games to meetups, the weight compounds quickly. Evacore and plastic inserts are typically under 1 pound added.
Game-Specific vs Universal
Game-specific inserts offer the best fit and organization but lock you into one game. Universal organizers like BitsBins and Gamegenic Token Silo work across multiple games but won’t perfectly fit any single one. Decide whether you want a tailored solution or a flexible one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What board games are most improved by custom inserts?
Games with 50+ components benefit most. Gloomhaven, Terraforming Mars, Wingspan, Catan with expansions, and Spirit Island all see dramatic setup time reductions – typically from 10-20 minutes down to under 5 minutes.
Do you buy game inserts or make your own?
Pre-made inserts from companies like Broken Token, TowerRex, Folded Space, and Laserox offer precision laser-cut parts with detailed instructions. DIY foam core is cheaper but requires significant time and crafting skill. Most gamers prefer buying for quality and time savings.
Are board game inserts worth the extra cost?
For games you play weekly or own expensive components, yes – inserts pay back the cost through time savings and component protection. For games played rarely or with inexpensive components, universal bins or DIY solutions offer better value.
Which insert company has the best quality?
Broken Token and TowerRex lead in wooden insert quality with precision laser cuts and durable materials. Folded Space excels at lightweight Evacore options. Gamegenic and BitsBins dominate the universal plastic organizer category.
Final Verdict
After testing all eight of these board game inserts, our top recommendation is the Broken Token Gloomhaven Organizer for serious strategy gamers, the Gamegenic Token Silo Convertible for versatile everyday use, and the BitsBins Combo Pack for budget-conscious buyers who want one organizer that works across multiple games.
The best board game inserts transform the gaming experience – cutting setup time dramatically, protecting valuable components, and making games feel more premium every time you open the box. Whether you choose a game-specific wooden insert for your favorite heavy strategy game or a universal modular system for casual titles, you’ll wonder how you ever played without one. Pick the insert that matches your most-played game, and your 2026 game nights will thank you.